Brooklyn and The Butcher

148 E Market St, New Albany, IN 47150, USA

About Brooklyn and The Butcher

4.5 / 5

from reviews

    Patrick Lewis
    -
    June 02, 2024

    Incredible experience! This building used to be an old old hotel. Well through the years it ended up being Brooklyn and the Butcher you see today You start with free complimentary bread and butter which was phenomenal With their menu you can expect it to roatate seasonally. So you will always see new dishes to try My wife had the shrimp linguine and I had a steak topped with mushrooms, tomatoes, and truffle oil. The food was great but THE SERVICE was even better. Our waitress was attentive, helpful, and took care of us well. We were so pleased. We went on a Friday night at 7 and it was not too busy. But aside from that we had a fantastic experience.

    Greg Naves II
    -
    January 04, 2024

    Went here for her birthday on a Wednesday night and it was very easy and fast to be seated. Our server Hannah was awesome , knowledgeable and made sure to check in often. We started with charcuterie board and lamb meatballs. The board was decent but not something I personally care for and the lamb meatballs were good but small. Not sure if worth the price to me. She ordered the Au Pivore and I got the ny strip medium cooked with a twice baked loaded potato and Mac and cheese. The main dishes were delicious. The ny strips we had were on par with most top steakhouses we visit and we enjoyed it. The twice baked potato was incredible and so were the whipped mash potatoes that came with her meal. Not a fan of the Mac and cheese. The house made lemonade was delicious and fresh and she enjoyed a couple glasses of moscato which she thought was good and smooth. The atmosphere is kid back and I like how it looks like a Victorian home renovated into a high class steakhouse . I recommend trying this place . We spent $194 on two appetizers , her meal and my meal plus drinks ( not including tip)

    Judy Bullard
    -
    November 06, 2023

    I had the Smash burger topped with an overeasy egg, fries, coffee and a Mimosa. Everything was delicious, but the fries had too much finishing salt. I brushed it off and was able to eat 1/2 of the fries. Great service and atmosphere. Many delicious items on their menu.

    Jess Buckner
    -
    May 30, 2023

    Birthday celebration at Brooklyn and The Butcher! Tried this restaurant at the recommendation of a coworker. Lovely place. Easy to find. Parking on the street was no issue. Nice ambience. Customer service from the door and throughout dinner was great. The server was excellent and very knowledgeable of the menu. I sadly forgot to get her name. We tried a couple her recommendations and weren't disappointed. All of my guests and including myself really enjoyed the Freedom Farm Lamb Meatballs. 🤌🏽 In addition to the pictures I included I also had the Caesar Salad with anchovies which was superb! The only reason I did not give 5 ⭐️ is because of my entree. I ordered the Beef Farm Sirloin Baseball Cut (Oscar styled). It was cooked medium, just as I ordered but a tad too crispy on the outside and the side of asparagus was a bit salty for my liking. Despite this, I am currently looking at my calendar to see when I can come back! 🙂

    Robbie McBurney
    -
    February 26, 2024

    Went here for our one year anniversary! Really great atmosphere, good spot for a romantic evening with talented musicians. Will definitely be coming here more often.

    Brooklyn and The Butcher

    Our Address

    148 E Market St, New Albany, IN 47150, USA

    Environmentally Conscious WebHost

    Read More

    Get An All-In-One Marketing Platform

    Read More

    Interested In Getting More Customers?

    Leverage Your Listing With Our Coupon Mailer!