Brooklyn and The Butcher

148 E Market St, New Albany, IN 47150, USA

About Brooklyn and The Butcher

4.5 / 5

from reviews

    Clutch Rockwell
    -
    December 22, 2024

    We were just blown away by the incredible bar staff. We drank well , ate wonderfully and laughed immensely. Such a blast this Saturday evening. Steak tar tar, old fashions to die for, smash burger off the hook. Just a perfect time. My favorite place since moving here 5 months ago.

    T Quamoh
    -
    November 01, 2024

    This spot is an unnoticed GEM where the service was impeccable, and the food was truly delightful. The generous portions were a pleasant surprise along with the bottomless mimosas. I will definitely bre going back.

    Dawn Polen
    -
    August 09, 2024

    We celebrated my retirement at Brooklyn and The Butcher, and everything was absolutely fabulous (as always)! Our entire meal was delicious and cooked to perfection, and the service was outstanding. As an added touch, there was a card with a nice note wishing me a happy retirement, and at the end of meal, we were brought complimentary chocolate covered strawberries - just lovely.

    Patrick Lewis
    -
    June 02, 2024

    Incredible experience! This building used to be an old old hotel. Well through the years it ended up being Brooklyn and the Butcher you see today You start with free complimentary bread and butter which was phenomenal With their menu you can expect it to roatate seasonally. So you will always see new dishes to try My wife had the shrimp linguine and I had a steak topped with mushrooms, tomatoes, and truffle oil. The food was great but THE SERVICE was even better. Our waitress was attentive, helpful, and took care of us well. We were so pleased. We went on a Friday night at 7 and it was not too busy. But aside from that we had a fantastic experience.

    Bryan Wood
    -
    February 07, 2025

    Had dinner with my adult daughter after too may years of not. First time at the restaurant (daughter lives in Louisville, she picked it). Food was ridiculously good; every bite. Salads, shrimp cocktail (cocktail sauce phenomenal and ASK for the HORSEradish sauce!!), lump crab, steaks cooked to perfection, red mashed and mac/cheese delightful. Dessert was decadent. Ambience perfect for a long chat meal and the waitstaff of Alex (training) and Amanda (great interactions) was top-notch. Can not wait to go back with my wife many times. Thank you Brooklyn and the Butcher.

    Brooklyn and The Butcher

    Our Address

    148 E Market St, New Albany, IN 47150, USA

    Environmentally Conscious WebHost

    Read More

    Get An All-In-One Marketing Platform

    Read More

    Interested In Getting More Customers?

    Leverage Your Listing With Our Coupon Mailer!