Cast Iron Steak House

1207 E Market St, Jeffersonville, IN 47130, USA

About Cast Iron Steak House

4.6 / 5

from reviews

    Christopher Parker
    -
    September 23, 2026

    Came to town to watch a little horse racing and casino fun. Found this place online. Walked, and was quickly seated. Cheyenne was our server, was super helpful on menu selections and just a pleasure. Wife and I both got the Delmonico steaks, side and salads. The home made ranch was really good. They were so yum. Cooked in a cast iron, great sear, and finished with a seasoning (unknown) and maybe a finishing oil or butter. Was really good. Menu also marked gluten free options and made easy for the wife to order.

    JW’s Grub & Adventures
    -
    May 30, 2026

    First time coming to this place. Our waitress, Ashlyn, was great! She was very informative of the menu, made sure we were taken care of. The food was great! The Mac and Cheese balls were delicious!!! Highly recommend. I got the Ribeye with boursin cheese. Very unique but I enjoyed it! My wife got the filet and it was under the first time so we had them take it back to cook longer. It was returned but unfortunately the steak did lose the seasoning. The manager came around to check on us and we mentioned the steak was a little under seasoned. He was nice enough to bring us a side of seasoning, which helped. The only thing i will say that needs to be improved is the parking. Almost had to cancel our reservations due to the lack of parking but ended up finding one. So glad I did, food was worthy enough for a return.

    misty kelley
    -
    June 05, 2026

    Visited on a Friday night at 6:30pm. We put a reservation in on their website 20 minutes prior. We got the last parking spot. We ordered the spinach artichoke dip for an appetizer. They gave us three different bread options to eat prior. I ordered the shrimp scampi pasta. It comes with a salad or side. My husband ordered a steak. He got two sides. He chose mashed potatoes and broccoli as his sides. They have high noon to drink. The flavor available that day was pear. We were there less than an hour so a quick turnaround. Most of the tables were full but the bar was empty and quiet.

    Jeanette Brown
    -
    August 02, 2026

    We stopped her on our way home so live about 40 mins away. We ordered on their website for carryout. We had to wait a few minutes later than the promised time it would be ready. They were crowded and busy so that is understandable. We had a long day ourselves and failed to check that we had received everything we ordered until we were on the bridge crossing into Kentucky. We did not receive our Caesar salad so I immediately called and asked if they could just refund the salad only and the manager/owner gave me a really hard time about it saying he cannot refund because Toast takes the payment. Then, he finally agreed to refund $5 which felt like an empty promise just to get me off the phone. Of course, it's been a week and no refund. If a business cannot afford to refund $5 for a mistake they made which they employees should remember they didn't pack a salad in the bags. The chicken sandwich was excellent except for the soggy bun and the mashed potatoes were not flavored well. The meatloaf was decent. Overall, we will not return here because of the service issues and from the other reviews, we aren't the only ones with service issues.

    Bobby Mowry
    -
    May 28, 2026

    Second time we have stopped in here and have to say it gets better everytime. Our waiter was on his job always made sure our drinks were full and if we needed anything. The food was as good as it was last time we were there. I order the catch of the day which was the grouper. The ol lady ordered a fancy named steak which I can’t remember the name of for the life of me now that I’m typing. But both were great and cooked perfect. If you’re in the area and want a great meal stop in and check them out well worth it.

    Cast Iron Steak House

    Our Address

    1207 E Market St, Jeffersonville, IN 47130, USA

    Interested In Getting More Customers?

    Leverage Your Listing With Our Coupon Mailer!