Ugh, I wrote a detailed review and it just disappeared. Not re- writing it. Just know it was great and we will come back.
The decor was fun with painted murals and designs covering every surface. I especially liked all the "climbing men" stationed around at various places. Agave & Rye Tequila and Bourbon Hall is mainly a taco place with a few other menu items. The tacos are not your usual run of the mil tacos and there are many delicious variations to choose from.
Being a non-drinker, I can't give you any info on the alcohol, but they seem to be pretty proud of it.
We did happy hour, 5$ mocktails, Pick 3 Chips and Dips, 15$, and the Three Taco Flight, 12$. It was plenty of food for the two of us and Eveything was delicious. We left just enough room for the huge piece of Chocolate Cake, $14. We ate the bottom two tiers and took the rest home. Yum.
Kyondre (Dre) was our server. What a delightful young man. He was very helpful and pleasant, while checking in on us frequently. IMHO, Agave & Rye is well worth a visit.
flash gordon
-
June 16, 2026
Awesome service started with the tall gentlemen that greets you on arrival. I ate at the bar and both the Lady and Gentleman did an awesome job. Returant very clean and restrooms super clean. I will be going back!!
Anastasia Rust
-
January 30, 2026
Amazing food and Kyle, our server was phenomenal with explaining each option and giving personal recommendations that we both went with and loved. Our drinks were great. Every taco was amazing. We visted during the snowy months, but the vibe would be such a fun summer spot too! We had two apps, two taco flights and two alcoholic beverages included in our check.
Doug O
-
April 07, 2026
Taco Tuesday! Three epic tacos, four variations from which to choose: bee's knees, Alderman, Plain Jane, Bang Bang. $4 each at the time of this review, $12 total. It looks so good couldn't resist having one before taking the picture. Corn tortilla wrapped with a flour one. Sizable portions as pictured. Great service, great atmosphere.
Sean Robinson
-
January 20, 2026
We came here once a while back and were not impressed. I'm so glad we decided to give it another try. The service and food was amazing! Our server, Robert, recommended the Bomb Taco and I agree 100%. He actually suggested getting it as a quesadilla which was even better. We also enjoyed the Swipe Right and Crown Jewel Tacos, as well as the Shrimp Rangoon with fried carrots. I think they should put the fried carrots as an appetizer itself, maybe with the Serrano Aoli. The bartender even went the extra mile to make us "skinny" margaritas! Overall it was an amazing experience. We even went back the very next day.
Our Address
324 E Main St, New Albany, IN 47150, USA
Claim Listing: Agave & Rye
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
Ugh, I wrote a detailed review and it just disappeared. Not re- writing it. Just know it was great and we will come back. The decor was fun with painted murals and designs covering every surface. I especially liked all the "climbing men" stationed around at various places. Agave & Rye Tequila and Bourbon Hall is mainly a taco place with a few other menu items. The tacos are not your usual run of the mil tacos and there are many delicious variations to choose from. Being a non-drinker, I can't give you any info on the alcohol, but they seem to be pretty proud of it. We did happy hour, 5$ mocktails, Pick 3 Chips and Dips, 15$, and the Three Taco Flight, 12$. It was plenty of food for the two of us and Eveything was delicious. We left just enough room for the huge piece of Chocolate Cake, $14. We ate the bottom two tiers and took the rest home. Yum. Kyondre (Dre) was our server. What a delightful young man. He was very helpful and pleasant, while checking in on us frequently. IMHO, Agave & Rye is well worth a visit.
Awesome service started with the tall gentlemen that greets you on arrival. I ate at the bar and both the Lady and Gentleman did an awesome job. Returant very clean and restrooms super clean. I will be going back!!
Amazing food and Kyle, our server was phenomenal with explaining each option and giving personal recommendations that we both went with and loved. Our drinks were great. Every taco was amazing. We visted during the snowy months, but the vibe would be such a fun summer spot too! We had two apps, two taco flights and two alcoholic beverages included in our check.
Taco Tuesday! Three epic tacos, four variations from which to choose: bee's knees, Alderman, Plain Jane, Bang Bang. $4 each at the time of this review, $12 total. It looks so good couldn't resist having one before taking the picture. Corn tortilla wrapped with a flour one. Sizable portions as pictured. Great service, great atmosphere.
We came here once a while back and were not impressed. I'm so glad we decided to give it another try. The service and food was amazing! Our server, Robert, recommended the Bomb Taco and I agree 100%. He actually suggested getting it as a quesadilla which was even better. We also enjoyed the Swipe Right and Crown Jewel Tacos, as well as the Shrimp Rangoon with fried carrots. I think they should put the fried carrots as an appetizer itself, maybe with the Serrano Aoli. The bartender even went the extra mile to make us "skinny" margaritas! Overall it was an amazing experience. We even went back the very next day.