Called in a cake order for my husband’s 50th birthday, and asked for a “Fiesta Themed” decoration. They went above and beyond, researching what that style should look like, and absolutely nailed the look I was after-AND the cake was so moist and delicious!! Everyone raved about it. Oh got a pumpkin roll while I was there, and it too was fantastic. Great baked goods and great service. Thanks so much!
Emily Sorensen
-
January 04, 2026
This cafe supersedes all other bakeries, coffee shops and dessert establishments of all time, everywhere. I have a nice layer of “warmth” around my midsection because I need a pie for every winter occasion and a treat for every homeschooling milestone we accomplish lol. My husbands favorite dessert of all time is the Dutch Caramel Apple Pie and mine is the Chocolate Cream. My daughters is the Strawberry Cream Cheese cake and my sons is the Chocolate Silk cake…meaning all our favorite desserts are from this business. My mother in law came to visit and I surprised her with an Oreo cake, she was IMPRESSED! This Christmas I also purchased treats for my neighbors from here. I bought the covered cupcakes and the Reindeer cookies. We seriously can’t get enough. I even get pup cups for my dog when he’s been with us. The ladies that run this place are phenomenal to work with. Every call ahead order is precise, affordable, beautiful and my name is even spelled correctly. Thank you dessert queens!
Pat McGroyne
-
November 30, 2025
We still love the treats here, but I removed a star. 30 bucks for a pumpkin pie is beyond excessive. I get it, everyone is getting their pound of flesh no matter what these days. There is simply no way to justify that price. No organic, free range, boutique, farm-to-table, small batch pie is worth that, even if it is baked by Amish elves in a tree. Supremely disappointed. Since the great city of New Albany has graced us once again with a bridge to access this place, we will still visit periodically. Good ice cream selection.. make it a malt or shake for an extra yummy treat (including whipped cream and a cherry on top!) Very good, apparently ultra-premium pies, and the ice cream is RIGHT there, so yes. I will have a scoop with my pie. Fantastic cakes and frosted cupcakes, too. The dining area is a cozy spot on a chilly evening. The service is never less than pleasant. Please try to keep the greed in check.
Kelly G
-
December 19, 2025
They had a very big selection and the lady was nice, but slap my face it's high dollar. Also, I make homemade pies and and this crust does not compare to real homemade as the name implies. However as I said they have a big selection and I did try a pie I had never had and it was good, she warmed it and WOWSER it was phenomenal. Just lacking in the crust and homemade-ness.
Dennis Fortner
-
November 04, 2025
Really good pie. I went there looking for Sugar Cream Pie. Unfortunately they did not have it. Tried the Chess pie, it was good not what I wanted but good. The service was great with friendly staff. Tables were very sticky feeling, not dirty, just in need of being revarnished. Overall good visit.
Our Address
3113 Blackiston Mill Rd, New Albany, IN 47150, USA
Claim Listing: Homemade Ice Cream and Pie Kitchen
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
Called in a cake order for my husband’s 50th birthday, and asked for a “Fiesta Themed” decoration. They went above and beyond, researching what that style should look like, and absolutely nailed the look I was after-AND the cake was so moist and delicious!! Everyone raved about it. Oh got a pumpkin roll while I was there, and it too was fantastic. Great baked goods and great service. Thanks so much!
This cafe supersedes all other bakeries, coffee shops and dessert establishments of all time, everywhere. I have a nice layer of “warmth” around my midsection because I need a pie for every winter occasion and a treat for every homeschooling milestone we accomplish lol. My husbands favorite dessert of all time is the Dutch Caramel Apple Pie and mine is the Chocolate Cream. My daughters is the Strawberry Cream Cheese cake and my sons is the Chocolate Silk cake…meaning all our favorite desserts are from this business. My mother in law came to visit and I surprised her with an Oreo cake, she was IMPRESSED! This Christmas I also purchased treats for my neighbors from here. I bought the covered cupcakes and the Reindeer cookies. We seriously can’t get enough. I even get pup cups for my dog when he’s been with us. The ladies that run this place are phenomenal to work with. Every call ahead order is precise, affordable, beautiful and my name is even spelled correctly. Thank you dessert queens!
We still love the treats here, but I removed a star. 30 bucks for a pumpkin pie is beyond excessive. I get it, everyone is getting their pound of flesh no matter what these days. There is simply no way to justify that price. No organic, free range, boutique, farm-to-table, small batch pie is worth that, even if it is baked by Amish elves in a tree. Supremely disappointed. Since the great city of New Albany has graced us once again with a bridge to access this place, we will still visit periodically. Good ice cream selection.. make it a malt or shake for an extra yummy treat (including whipped cream and a cherry on top!) Very good, apparently ultra-premium pies, and the ice cream is RIGHT there, so yes. I will have a scoop with my pie. Fantastic cakes and frosted cupcakes, too. The dining area is a cozy spot on a chilly evening. The service is never less than pleasant. Please try to keep the greed in check.
They had a very big selection and the lady was nice, but slap my face it's high dollar. Also, I make homemade pies and and this crust does not compare to real homemade as the name implies. However as I said they have a big selection and I did try a pie I had never had and it was good, she warmed it and WOWSER it was phenomenal. Just lacking in the crust and homemade-ness.
Really good pie. I went there looking for Sugar Cream Pie. Unfortunately they did not have it. Tried the Chess pie, it was good not what I wanted but good. The service was great with friendly staff. Tables were very sticky feeling, not dirty, just in need of being revarnished. Overall good visit.