Homemade Ice Cream and Pie Kitchen

3113 Blackiston Mill Rd, New Albany, IN 47150, USA

About Homemade Ice Cream and Pie Kitchen

4.5 / 5

from reviews

    Nathan Hurt
    -
    May 11, 2022

    Alrighty, we went here for a special treat for my son's birthday. We came here just for the ice cream, but they had so much more. They had lots of pie varieties, cake varieties, cheesecake varieties and a ton of ice cream flavors. We went around 1 or 2 p.m. and there was no one else in there on a weekday. It had a very nice cozy Bakery type of atmosphere with seating inside and outside. Good prices and the one employee there was extremely nice. If we lived closer, we would probably visit more often and try their other Bakery items.

    Jennifer Williams
    -
    March 15, 2024

    Walked in with my kids and it took me to say hello to the 4 staff members who were too "busy" to help us, to be acknowledged and served. There was not a single customer in site. This has happened a few times and this will be my last coming here. On top of the fact the guy that rang us up wiped his nose with his gloved hands 3 times and did not change them once! Oh then a customer walked in after us and was helped immediately. Welp another person was acknowledged as I write this. Starting to wonder if my appearance is why. I don't expect Michelin star service, but to sit and stare at us for a minute or two is wild.

    Amy Bowden
    -
    April 28, 2024

    My husband ordered a Kentucky Bourbon milkshake. I ordered the strawberry rhubarb pie. Both choices were excellent and we will definitely be back!

    Nick Carbonaro
    -
    July 06, 2021

    Really good ice cream and pie! Homemade and nobody was in so it was really good! My wife and son got pies and cake and my daughter got ice cream. Portion sizes are huge!!! My daughters was a double scoop and I had split into two cups!

    A. W.
    -
    September 05, 2022

    Menu prices currently shown on google are incorrect. It's even more expensive cause I just went in. There is no menu with updated prices inside. You find out when you check out. It was already overpriced before. I feel like everything is decent but not worth the cost. Been here few times and it's nothing mind blowing. Ice cream is made in house apparently but tastes the same as anywhere. My birthday cake ice cream had more cake than ice cream in it. I agree with another review that the inside is lacking a welcoming and fun atmosphere. Staff tonight was certainly not very welcoming but that doesn't bother me much. 3 out of 5 stars seems about right.

    Homemade Ice Cream and Pie Kitchen

    Our Address

    3113 Blackiston Mill Rd, New Albany, IN 47150, USA

    Environmentally Conscious WebHost

    Read More

    Get An All-In-One Marketing Platform

    Read More

    Interested In Getting More Customers?

    Leverage Your Listing With Our Coupon Mailer!